Skip to content
Medium

Medium

Read writing from Avi Loeb on Medium. Avi Loeb is the Baird Professor of Science at Harvard U. and a bestselling author. Check out his YouTube Channel at: https://www.youtube.com/@ProfessorAviLoeb

avi-loeb.medium.com
MediumMedium
EARTH SPACE CLIMATE AND ENVIRONMENT

Is 1998 KY26 a Dark Comet or the Phobos 1 Spacecraft?

(Image Credit: Omer Eldadi) Below is a transcript of an interview I had this morning here in Fox Weather. Questions are marked in boldface fonts below. ******* You may have heard about this debate in space. A Harvard astrophysicist argues that what’s been named 1998 KY26 is a former Soviet spacecraft lost in space for nearly 30 years, Phobos 1. Other scientists suggest it’s just an asteroid or a dark comet. NASA’s Administrator, Jared Isaacman, went on Fox News, saying this space object is nothing more than an asteroid. He said: “First of all, nothing is about to hit us, to be very clear on this. There is an asteroid out there that I think some of the UAP community is observing and think it’s making some unusual maneuvering out there. I’ve not seen any evidence to suggest this is a threat to our planet or anything other than an asteroid. I promise you, we’ll keep our eyes on it. We love theories, too.” Now, shortly afterwards the Japanese Space Agency, which initially planned to investigate this unknown object with their asteroid sampling spacecraft, changed their mind. They changed course. The agency says that a malfunctioning of one of the four engines on their probe was the reason why they changed course and will no longer investigate this object. But why? And what even is this unidentified thing floating in space? Joining us now to further that discussion, we have astrophysicist and Harvard Professor of Science, Avi Loeb. Avi, thank you for joining us. The image of this object looks like a tooth to me. But I know that that is not one of the theories floating around. It is so interesting. We want to get your opinion on some of the new developments, because even if the Japanese Space Agency did get their probe there, it wasn’t expected to arrive until 2031. So even then, we’d have to wait another five years for confirmation, but what do you make of these new developments? Thanks for having me. First, a few corrections. This object was not monitored by UAP enthusiasts. It was monitored by astronomers. In addition, it’s not an asteroid because we know that it exhibits non-gravitational acceleration. There is some push on this object, which is mysterious because we don’t see any gas or dust coming off it. Therefore, it is not a comet in the traditional sense where you see a cometary tail. That’s why NASA’s Administrator Jared Isaacman calls it an asteroid, but if it were a rock, an asteroid, there would be no push, because it would just follow gravity whereas this object has non gravitational acceleration. So, we looked at the orbit of this object around the Sun, and we found that it’s very similar to that of the Phobos 1 spacecraft that was launched by the Soviets in 1988. Moreover, this object is roughly 10 meters in size, comparable to the scale of a spacecraft. We don’t have an image of it. The image you saw is just a reconstruction from a radar that is not very accurate. But the size of the object is comparable to that of Phobos 1 and it is very shiny. Astronomers measured that it reflects half of the sunlight that is impinging on it. An asteroid typically reflects about 5% of the sunlight shining on it. In this case, we’re seeing a very shiny object, and moreover it’s spinning every five minutes, and if this was a collection of rocks that are glued together by ice, they wouldn’t stick together at such a high spinning rate. With my co-authors Adam Hibberd and Adam Crawl, we calculated here that the push on this object can be explained in terms of reflection of sunlight by the solar panels of Phobos 1. The sunlight reflecting off these solar panels is pushing them, just like a sail on a boat. We calculated that the observed non gravitational acceleration is just what you expect from the solar panels of the Phobos 1 spacecraft. We are saying: let’s check if this is a spacecraft, Phobos 1, or a dark comet, namely a mysterious object that is losing invisible gas. Arguing that it is a dark comet reminds me of Hans Christian Anderson’s tale, where the adults in the room insist: “The emperor has clothes. You just can’t see them.” In this case, all the officials and comet experts are saying: “It’s a comet, but you just can’t see the outgassing or dust that usually surrounds a comet.” We said: “Great, the Japanese Space Agency plans to land on it, so we will be able to tell whether it’s an iceberg or whether there is a label: “Made in the U.S.S.R.” on it.” But now the Japanese decided not to visit this object, so unfortunately, we will not have that opportunity. However, I hope that next year, we’ll have additional data from the Webb telescope that will settle the issue, and that is the way science is done. It’s not done by NASA’s administrator saying conclusively that he knows the answer. That’s not the way to make progress. The way to make progress is to collect data by NASA’s Webb telescope, rather than follow NASA’s administrator. Thank you for the clarification. The images from the Webb telescope will be very helpful. And just to be clear too, whenever we heard Jared Isaacman mention the UAP community, UAP stands for Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena. You are part of the UAP community. So, when all of this happened over the weekend, and we heard that the Japan’s Space Agency was changing course, what came to your mind? Why would a possible reason for that happen? It reminded me of Galileo Galilei who was the first scientist to use a telescope to look at the sky. He realized that there are moons around Jupiter, and he informed the Vatican about it, and the clergy did not go and look through his telescope to see the evidence. Instead, they put him in house arrest. So, when there is some anomalous data, something that doesn’t line up with what we know, most people prefer not to look at the evidence, to just ignore it, and argue everything is the same. 1998 KY26 is a rock, we don’t need to worry about it. And I just think it’s not the right approach for a curious scientist. As scientists, we should be open to the possibility that we’re missing something. Now, why is this important? In this case, it’s not so important because, whether this object is Phobos 1 or an asteroid wouldn’t have a major impact on anything. But there was an object from interstellar space called Oumuamua, which was discovered in 2017. It behaved in a strange way and was also named a dark comet. There was no gas or dust around it, but it was pushed away from the sun by some non-gravitational force. I suggested it might be technological. In that case, we know for sure that Oumuamua came from outside the Solar System. So, if it was technological, it would mean that there is a space agency outside the Solar System near another star that sent it. That’s why it’s so consequential. We need to be able to distinguish technological objects in space from rocks or icebergs. And right now, NASA and the mainstream of the astronomy community keep insisting that everything we see in the sky must be rocks or icebergs. I love one of the quotes I found from you on Fox News. You said: “Innovation in science requires imagination. It requires you to allow for the possibility that our knowledge is incomplete, and that’s how humans are, that’s how we grow as we continue to learn more.” I want to ask you a final question before we leave. Voyager 1 has been getting a lot of attention today, because it just hit this incredible milestone, reaching a distance of one light day, which doesn’t seem like much, but it is. On board Voyager 1, is a golden record from 1977. And that golden record serves as a message to anybody who may find it in space. Do you ever expect this record to come in contact with anybody? I hope it will not be found by aliens, because we are doing better now than we did in the 1960s, and we will do better in the future. I’m not very proud of the music that we had back in the ’60s. I think we did much better since then. And, you know, frankly, it’s very arrogant of us to brag, because if any technological civilization finds us, it is much more likely that they are far more advanced than we are. So instead of bragging and being proud of what we produced, we should look at them and learn from them. We need a sense of humility when we study the sky in order to learn from the most accomplished siblings in our family of intelligent civilizations. Traditionally, religions brought a sense of humility, because they argued for a superhuman entity, God. And now, a lot of people are secular and they don’t believe in that. But if we do find that we have a sibling that is far more accomplished than we are, it will bring back a sense of humility, and that, I think, is what we need the most. I think to approach it humbly is really an effective way, and we can learn a lot of things about our life as humans when we look out there. This was a great conversation. Thank you for taking part again in the debate. Great having you, Harvard Professor of Science, Avi Loeb. Thank you for joining us. We appreciate you. (Image credit: Fox Weather) ABOUT THE AUTHOR (Image credit: Lotem Loeb) Avi Loeb is chair of the UAP Science Advisory Council to the White House, Pentagon, FBI and intelligence agencies, director of the Galileo Project, founding director of Harvard University’s — Black Hole Initiative (2016–2021), former director of the Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (2005–2026), and the former chair of the astronomy department at Harvard University (2011–2020). He is a former member of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2018–2019) and a former chair of the Board on Physics and Astronomy of the National Academies (2018–2021). He is the bestselling author of “Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth” and a co-author of the textbook “Life in the Cosmos”, both published in 2021. The paperback edition of his new book, titled “Interstellar”, was published in August 2024. Professional website: https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/ Social media: https://avi-loeb.medium.com/ https://www.youtube.com/@ProfessorAviLoeb https://open.spotify.com/show/1zhndXkvSY2b8FdjspFpCd https://x.com/ProfAviLoeb
JAPANJARED ISAACMANOMER ELDADI
MediumMedium
EARTH SPACE CLIMATE AND ENVIRONMENT

An Executive Summary of the Universe

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt) The Universe started simple. We can summarize its initial conditions on a single sheet of paper. For people with a short attention span, let me give the executive summary. The Universe started expanding from a hot and dense phase, containing a soup of matter and radiation with a nearly uniform distribution. The tiny deviations from uniformity were at a level of one part in 100,000 but they were highly consequential. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) Once the radiation cooled enough for matter to dominate the mass budget, the density fluctuations grew gravitationally. The smallest and densest regions collapsed to make the first generation of galaxies about 100 million years after the Big Bang. They gave birth to the first stars. These stars represent our cosmic roots. They flag the cosmic transition from simplicity to complexity. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) The continuous progression from simplicity to complexity triggered the arrow of time and culminated in the formation of intelligent life today. We tend to think that our intelligence is the pinnacle of creation, but it is likely that more intelligent creatures existed on exoplanets long before us. To find them, we must give up the arrogant belief that intelligence is limited to Earth and that astrobiology should focus on the search for microbes. If we will not search for siblings in our family of intelligent civilizations, we will never find them. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) But there is a bigger lesson to be learned from this executive summary: life was a byproduct of cosmic evolution, but the Universe was not designed to have life in it. There are several examples of missed cosmic opportunities for life. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) First, the expanding Universe missed an opportunity to fuse protons and neutrons into the heavy elements that make life: carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, phosphorus and sulfur. The high temperatures and densities suitable for nuclear reactions lasted only a few minutes after the Big Bang and led only to the formation of hydrogen and helium with a dash of lithium. Second, rocky planets arrived too late and missed an opportunity to give birth to early life when the Universe was at room temperature, 10 million years after the Big Bang. If planets had existed at that early time, they could have given birth to life at any location without being limited to the habitable zones around stars. The entire Universe was habitable for a few million years at a redshift of about 100. Unfortunately, this transient fertility period was missed because no planets existed that early. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) This must be disappointing news to all self-centered humans. The pregnancy of the universe with life is apparently an afterthought, a byproduct of complex circumstances and not a result of careful design. The initial conditions of the Universe could have been better optimized for the emergence of life. I am not complaining about the fact that we could have inherited a better Universe. I am just saying that nobody had us in mind when the Universe started, because the initial conditions could have been better precursors for life. This is all understandable. We now know that we are not at the center of the Universe and that we arrived late to the cosmic play. If you are not centerstage and you arrive late in a complex play, the play is not about you. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) Owing to the lack of heavy elements, the primordial gas was unable to cool efficiently and fragmented into stars more massive than the Sun. The first massive stars were efficient factories of ultraviolet photons. These photons broke (ionized) hydrogen atoms into their constituent electrons and protons, in a process called reionization. At the high temperature that prevailed during the first 0.4 million years after the Big Bang, these atoms were already ionized, but subsequently electrons combined with protons once the Universe cooled below a few thousand degrees. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) During reionization, bubbles of ionized hydrogen surrounded the first galaxies. As more ultraviolet photons were produced by new massive stars, the ionized bubbles expanded. The volume of each ionized bubble included a number of atoms that matched the number of ionizing photons produced within that bubble. Eventually nearby bubbles merged and percolated until the entire Universe was reionized a billion years after the Big Bang. The first galaxies formed in the highest density regions. These regions first collapsed in one dimension — making sheets of dense matter, then collapsed along the second dimension -making filaments at the intersection of sheets, and finally drained the matter along the third dimension of the filaments into galaxies at the intersection of these filaments. At any given snapshot, cosmic structure looks like a complex network of filaments and sheets. The first ionized bubbles grew out of the intersection of filaments, just like fruits stemming out of the branches in a tree. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) The ionized bubbles grew in size over time. After a billion years, the fruits consumed the volume of the entire tree. Today, most of the ordinary matter in the Universe is in the form of an ionized gas, so-called a plasma of free electrons and protons. (Image credit: Greg Wyatt) *** In this essay, I featured ten amazingly beautiful watercolors from a series created and sent to me by the celebrated artist, Greg Wyatt. The detailed physics of the epoch of reionization is summarized in my textbooks: “How Did the First Stars and Galaxies Form?” here, and “The First Galaxies in the Universe” here. The origin of life is discussed in my textbook “Life in the Cosmos” here. *** ABOUT THE AUTHOR (Image Credit: Lotem Loeb, May 22, 2026) Avi Loeb is chair of the UAP Science Advisory Council to the White House, Pentagon, FBI and intelligence agencies, director of the Galileo Project, founding director of Harvard University’s — Black Hole Initiative (2016–2021), former director of the Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (2005–2026), and the former chair of the astronomy department at Harvard University (2011–2020). He is a former member of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2018–2019) and a former chair of the Board on Physics and Astronomy of the National Academies (2018–2021). He is the bestselling author of “Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth” and a co-author of the textbook “Life in the Cosmos”, both published in 2021. The paperback edition of his new book, titled “Interstellar”, was published in August 2024. Professional website: https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/ Social media: https://avi-loeb.medium.com/ https://www.youtube.com/@ProfessorAviLoeb https://open.spotify.com/show/1zhndXkvSY2b8FdjspFpCd https://x.com/ProfAviLoeb
INTERSTELLARNATIONAL ACADEMIES
MediumMedium
EARTH SPACE CLIMATE AND ENVIRONMENT

JAXA Cancels Trip to the “Dark Comet” 1998 KY26 a Day After Avi Loeb Argued It Might Be the…

### JAXA Cancels Trip to the “Dark Comet” 1998 KY26 a Day After Avi Loeb Argued It Might Be the Spacecraft Phobos 1 (Image credit: Omer Eldadi) Over the past few days, a statement I made was featured all over the news (for example, here, here, here and here) including in a tweet which received more than a million views here. NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said on Fox & Friends: “I’ve not seen any evidence to suggest this is…anything other than an asteroid.” On the other hand, I argued a few hours later here on Fox News that this so-called “dark comet” 1998KY98 is more likely the lost soviet spacecraft Phobos 1. This argument was based on the detailed quantitative analysis presented in two papers that I co-authored with Adam Hibberd and Adam Crawl, which were posted here and here. These papers received major scrutiny from the editors and referees of scientific journals as well as self-declared experts and influencers on social media. In reference to the pushback that the two papers received and the lack of references to our work in the subsequent scientific literature, I wrote to my co-authors: “Comet experts and referees can play games and a viable alternative interpretation of all existing data for now. But after the rendezvous of the Hayabusa 2 spacecraft by the Japanese Space Agency (JAXA) with 1998 KY26 in July 2031, these dogmatists will have to admit the truth. As the Vatican learned from the Galileo affair, knowing the truth cannot be avoided, only delayed.” Needless to say, I was disappointed when this morning, JAXA announced here that they “decided to abandon its plan to reach asteroid 1998 KY26, the final destination of the Hayabusa 2 probe. The decision was made due to engine problems that significantly exceeded the design life, and the probe will now head to a different asteroid.” JAXA reported this at a meeting of the Cabinet Office’s Space Policy Committee on Monday November 16, 2026. According to this new report, in mid-August the fourth of Hayabusa 2’s main engines malfunctioned. The spacecraft switched to a mode which uses the usable parts of two malfunctioning engines, but this resulted in a loss of thrust. Reaching 1998 KY26 in July 2031 requires a gravity assist maneuver near Earth but JAXA’s decision was to change the destination to a flyby near the asteroid 2015 BM510. What is the probability that JAXA reached this decision less than a day after my media appearances about the possibility that 1998 KY26 might be Phobos 1? The answer can be quantified. The malfunctioning of Hayabusa 2’s engines was known for more than three months. The random chance of a decision being made within less than a day after my public appearances is less than 1%. This strongly suggests a correlation between JAXA’s decision and my media appearances. *** In my interviews, I was often asked by reporters: “What is the evidence for the association of the so-called “dark comet” 1998 KY26 with the spacecraft Phobos 1?” My answer was as follows. First, the orbit of 1998 KY26 is very close to that of the Russian probe Phobos 1, which suffered a failure 2 months after the launch in July 1988, due to upload of a faulty command. The first paper I co-authored here shows that by matching the trajectories of Phobos 1 and 1998 KY26. Second, 1998 KY26 exhibits a non-gravitational push away from the Sun with no detectable shedding of gas or dust, as expected from the rocket effect of a comet. Our second paper here explains this push as the result of the reflection of sunlight by the solar panels of Phobos 1. Remarkably, we found that the anomalous non-gravitational acceleration and the brightness variation of 1998 KY26 can both be explained by the reflection of sunlight from Phobos 1 with its solar panels. Recent radar and optical observations of 1998 KY26 indicate an unusually rapid spin-rate with a period of 5.35 minutes which is much faster than a natural pile of rocks glued by ice can sustain. The observations also implied a diameter of order 10 meters, and a shiny surface which reflects 52% of the sunlight impinging on it, both facts that are consistent with expectations from the Phobos 1 spacecraft. The insistence of comet experts on the hypothesis that 1998 KY26 is a dark comet and their refusal to acknowledge the competing hypothesis that it is a technological object rather than an iceberg, underline how dogmatic the scientific mainstream has become. Last week, a new paper published here in the prestigious scientific journal Icarus, reported that all locations on the surface or in the interior of 1998 KY26 are too hot for a comet. The orbit-averaged temperatures significantly above the sublimation point of volatiles in vacuum. These results indicate that the water outgassing rate on 1998 KY26 would be too high to maintain buried ice. On the other hand, the results are consistent with the interpretation that 1998 KY26 is the lost soviet spacecraft Phobos 1. Nevertheless, the authors of this paper ignored this possibility and chose not to cite the two papers that I co-authored on this subject here and here. Just this morning, I was asked by Amanda Greenwood from Newsweek (in an interview published here before JAXA’s new announcement): “Do you expect JAXA’s planned Hayabusa 2 encounter in 2031 to provide a definitive answer?” My answer was as follows. Comet experts believe that 1998 KY26 is an iceberg, and they want to visit it. As a result, the Japanese Space Agency JAXA plans to land the Hayabusa 2 spacecraft on this object in July 2031. My alternative prediction is that when they land on it and study the properties of what they regard to be a mysterious iceberg that has invisible gas coming from it, they will find out instead the label: “Made in the U.S.S.R.” on it. But now, as a result of the new decision by JAXA, we might never know for sure if 1998 KY26 and Phobos 1 are the same. This might make some dogmatists happy because they will not be proven wrong, but it goes against the spirit of the scientific method. Alternative interpretations should be tested by experimental data. When there is concern that the mainstream view might be wrong, we should aim to obtain missing data rather than avoid it. *** Dark comets are a proposed class of curious hybrids between comets and asteroids. These objects show significant non-gravitational accelerations, yet they exhibit absolutely no sign of cometary outgassing in the form of a coma or tail. The first recognized interstellar object, *Oumuamua*, showed these features and was suggested to be a dark comet’ in recent mainstream publications, such as here. However, based on its inferred flat shape (published here) and non-gravitational acceleration (published here), I argued 8 years ago here that Oumuamua* might be pushed by sunlight and is technological in origin. The dark comet categorization of *Oumuamua and similar solar system objects was the mainstream response to my nontraditional suggestion. The stakes for *Oumuamua* being technological in origin are much higher than for *1998 KY26*, because its high speed cannot be of human origin. Realizing that *1998 KY26* is technological rather than a dark comet’ would suggest that maybe comet experts should not be trusted and Oumuamua* is the first encounter of astronomers with alien technology. As I said all along, Elon Musk is probably not the most accomplished space entrepreneur over the past 13.8 billion years. There are billions of homes similar to Earth in our cosmic street of the Milky-Way galaxy and it is unreasonable to suggest that there are no space agencies beyond Earth that could have given birth to *Oumuamua. ABOUT THE AUTHOR (Image Credit: Lotem Loeb, May 22, 2026) Avi Loeb is chair of the UAP Science Advisory Council to the White House, Pentagon, FBI and intelligence agencies, director of the Galileo Project, founding director of Harvard University’s — Black Hole Initiative (2016–2021), former director of the Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (2005–2026), and the former chair of the astronomy department at Harvard University (2011–2020). He is a former member of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2018–2019) and a former chair of the Board on Physics and Astronomy of the National Academies (2018–2021). He is the bestselling author of “Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth” and a co-author of the textbook “Life in the Cosmos”, both published in 2021. The paperback edition of his new book, titled “Interstellar”, was published in August 2024. Professional website: https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/ Social media: https://avi-loeb.medium.com/ https://www.youtube.com/@ProfessorAviLoeb https://open.spotify.com/show/1zhndXkvSY2b8FdjspFpCd https://x.com/ProfAviLoeb
GALILEOADAM HIBBERDADAM CRAWL
Nautilus | Science ConnectedThe New York Times - Breaking News, US News, World News and VideosMeteored US
MediumMedium
EARTH SPACE CLIMATE AND ENVIRONMENT

A Mysterious Space Object Accelerates Towards Earth as Scientists Debate Its Origin

(Image Credit: Fox News) Yesterday, I tweeted here the headline: “Mysterious space object accelerates towards Earth as scientists debate”. This tweet about the object labeled 1998 KY26 received about a million views within a day. Below are more details on the context, in the form of the transcript of the second among two follow-up interviews (here and here) that I had with Fox Corporation. Questions are marked in boldface fonts below. *** A strange object is moving through the solar system, and it’s leading to more questions than answers. Here, we have the man with the answers, Professor of Science at Harvard University, Avi Loeb joins us now to discuss this object. Great to have you with us, as always. Let me jump into it. What’s your take on this object? Thanks for having me. Comet experts argue that this object, labeled 1998 KY26, is a dark comet because a non-gravitational force appears to be pushing it away from the Sun, but we can’t see any signs of a cometary outgassing that would give it this push through the rocket effect on a regular comet. Therefore, they classify it as a dark comet. What we noticed with my colleagues, Adam Hibberd and Adam Crawl, is that this object follows a similar trajectory to that of a lost Soviet spacecraft, Phobos 1, which was launched in 1988. Recent observations of 1998 KY26 indicate that it is very shiny reflecting roughly half of the sunlight that is impinging on it. It has a size of roughly 11 meters, comparable to that of the Phobos 1 spacecraft. We calculated that the reflection of sunlight from the solar panels of Phobos 1 can give this spacecraft the non-gravitational push and the light curve observed for 1998 KY26. And so, everything fits. Nevertheless, comet experts in the mainstream of the astronomy community still believe that 1998 KY26 is an iceberg, and they want to visit it. As a result, the Japanese Space Agency JAXA will land the Hayabusa 2 spacecraft on this object in July 2031. Our alternative prediction is that when they land on it and study the properties of what they regard to be a mysterious iceberg that has invisible gas coming from it, they will find out instead the label: “Made in the U.S.S.R.” on it. This is so fascinating. I just think about what it takes to land on this object in space, and then identify exactly all those details that you just mentioned. And if it was something that was discovered in 1998, why are we just now studying it? 1998 KY26 had been monitored over the years, but now there is this plan to visit it and learn more about it because it is classified as a mysterious dark comet. The reason that the dark comet concept was invented is because of another object from outside the solar system called Oumuamua*, which was discovered in 2017. *Oumuamua also showed non gravitational acceleration without any outgassing of gas or dust around it. And so, the comet experts argued that Oumuamua* is a dark comet, and I argued that perhaps the sunlight is pushing it. In that case, *Oumuamua might be a technological object like Phobos 1, because Oumuamua* had to be very thin unlike any rock that we are familiar with. To me, it would be a teaching moment if we visit *1998 KY26* and find that it is technological in origin, namely the *Phobos 1* spacecraft launched by the Soviets, because it would show that maybe *Oumuamua was launched by an alien space agency from another star. You are saying that the Sun’s energy could be propelling these objects. Indeed, the sunlight can push technological objects which are relatively thin, just like a sailboat being pushed by the wind. Similarly to the air bouncing off a sail, sunlight reflecting off an object that is sufficiently thin or hollow ends up pushing it to measurable levels. In the case of Phobos 1, the solar panels were large and sufficiently thin to give it the observed push. That’s fascinating. Fascinating. And then I think about this other thing that’s pretty fascinating. You were also tapped by the White House to lead the UAP Science Advisory Council, where UAP means Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena. A few days ago, you also shared plans to develop a system of specifically designed telescopes. Please tell us a little bit about that. Yes, in fact a couple of days ago, I visited the Pentagon to discuss this new observatory concept. In the seven tranches of released files by the Presidential Unsealing and Reporting System for UAP Encounters, there are videos of unidentified objects. Some of them look like orbs, namely glowing balls of light that do not resemble drones or other technological objects manufactured by humans. A couple of months ago, I came up here with the idea of a new observatory concept, which includes a radar system monitoring the sky for these orbs. Once a UAP of interest is spotted, a large telescope, roughly a meter in size, is steered in the direction of the UAP and takes a high-resolution image of it. A meter-scale telescope can resolve a green pea out to a distance to a few kilometers. It can resolve passengers through the windows of an airplane. Such a high-resolution image will give us a lot of new information about UAP. But in addition, we plan to have a spectrograph that will take a spectrum of the UAP, allowing us to infer its composition. Within a couple of months after I imagined this observatory concept, I received a donation of the $1.5M needed to fund it. We are planning to put the first prototype in the old residence of Carl Sagan in Ithaca, New York, in celebration of Sagan’s legacy. My main goal is to help the Pentagon and the intelligence community fulfill their national security missions. With the new data, we will know if we are dealing with some black project from an adversarial nation that is spying on the US. If instead some UAP represent alien technology from out of this world, finding them would be the biggest discovery ever made by humanity. This is the most fascinating conversation that I’ve had in a while. Okay, this is a little off script, but I’m sure you’ve seen it. Recently, there was a jellyfish-like flying object in Alaska. Have you seen that, and what are your thoughts? Yes, in fact, there were jellyfish reports already in the videos released by the Pentagon. By the way, there were about 3 billion views of these videos over the past 5 months, indicating a huge public interest in this subject. My tweet on 1998 KY26 yesterday here received a million views within one day! Clearly, there is a huge audience for unusual space objects, and the jellyfish objects were also observed in the Middle East and in other locations, where the military monitors the sky for national security purposes. Every now and then military personnel see something really unusual, and the type of objects that were reported are either jellyfish, orbs, or triangles, and all of these look strange. I spoke with people at the Pentagon and asked them: Why don’t you assume that these are all human made technologies?’, and they replied: “Because the data is not consistent with what we know.’ They don’t have sufficient data to inform them that it’s alien technology, not human made. So, the interpretation is still open. We need better data and that’s what I’m aiming to get in partnership with them. **This is such a fascinating topic of conversation. The fact that the tweet and the videos have had so many views shows where the public’s interest is.** **Well, this has been such an amazing conversation. It’s great to have you back on the show, Professor of Science at Harvard University, Avi Loeb. Thank you for your time this morning.** Thanks for having me. When we have better answers, I’ll be glad to speak with you again. ******* *(Image Credit: [Fox News](https://www.foxnews.com/video/6408340989112))* #### *Addendum: the scientific context* Last week, a new paper published [here](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0019103526004276) in the prestigious scientific journal *Icarus*, reported that all locations on the surface or in the interior of *1998 KY26* have orbit-averaged temperatures significantly above the sublimation point of volatiles in vacuum. These results indicate that the water outgassing rate on *1998 KY26* would be too high to maintain buried ice. Even though the results are consistent with the interpretation that *1998 KY26* is the lost soviet spacecraft *Phobos 1*, the authors of this paper ignored this possibility and chose not to cite the two papers that I co-authored on this subject with Adam Hibberd and Adam Crowl, [here](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2606.01288) and [here](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2609.24283). In reference to the aggressive pushback that our two papers received from comet experts and the lack of references to our work in this new paper, I wrote to my co-authors: “Comet experts and referees can play games and suppress a fair assessment of the existing data for now. But after the Hayabusa 2 spacecraft of the Japanese Space Agency (JAXA) lands on *1998 KY26* in July 2031, these dogmatists will eventually have to admit the truth. As the Vatican learned from the Galileo affair, knowing the truth cannot be avoided, only delayed.” Our first paper [here](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2606.01288) suggested the hypothesis that *1998 KY26* may be a relic of the Russian probe *Phobos 1*, which suffered a failure 2 months after the launch in July 1988, due to upload of a faulty command by matching the trajectories of *Phobos 1* and *1998 KY26*. Our second paper [here](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2609.24283) analyzed recent radar and optical observation of *1998 KY26* which indicated an unusually rapid spin-rate with a period of 5.35 minutes (much faster than an icy rubble pile can sustain), a diameter of 11 ± 2 meters, and a shiny surface which reflects 52% of the sunlight. We explained the observed level and direction of the non-gravitational acceleration of *1998 KY26* with no detectable shedding of gas or dust, as a result of the reflection of sunlight by the solar panels of *Phobos 1*. This reflection also explains reasonably well the inferred shape and the observed light curve of *1998 KY26*. The insistence of comet experts on the hypothesis that *1998 KY26* is a dark comet and their refusal to acknowledge the competing hypothesis that it is a technological object rather than an iceberg underline how dogmatic the scientific mainstream has become. Dark comets are a proposed class of curious hybrids between comets and asteroids. These objects show significant non-gravitational accelerations, yet they exhibit absolutely no sign of cometary outgassing in the form of a coma or tail. The first recognized interstellar object, *1I/Oumuamua*, showed these features and was suggested to be a dark comet’ in a recent mainstream publication [here](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2412.07603). However, based on its inferred flat shape (published [here](https://watermark02.silverchair.com/stz2380.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE49Ooan9kkhW_Ercy7Dm3ZL_9Cf3qfKAc485ysgAAA2swggNnBgkqhkiG9w0BBwagggNYMIIDVAIBADCCA00GCSqGSIb3DQEHATAeBglghkgBZQMEAS4wEQQMRt813awx5Ttb3mr-AgEQgIIDHn2pcJrAWAqgrVFlZIz_2I5YhDvbWqR4uZhsEGo-USzvRek5i45GZO8at14v3ZLQA68ZzCLpOeuCp179hw0h0rTUgTTkc4igu3nIuU3_ioodOYPypKjCa8_7NZ9UJgwq3dJ7useEbsq9jqPqAY8QCgkHYs0YWSrVlIRrTVi0Yuz-UDPtIvK4KxTDrkhHYiFYbLg7l3RrbgYotJfQ7FaCDADAV49HIE3H2FrAF4k5IkKtATisuC5UyF8tVX8vzoAQX1uP4HkNDlCyz9ISZh7kHz_eWhM0cy5dtaZc_AP-eAPi52zat6tZ1k5dwmgoTeAuGJtGE72tKFXEDyd5pjNgnV1vnqcHfpAekWBk6GAUQieCXWj_wnQbe-uPPJuInSEaM_TEz__oToNjooWAdgA-ayP9Lm38jpZ7iH8m_PjW8yoRmGT_0L1wXHjRm81wYJjYC8a1Gw1wTSXfGg0RZ732k00g73pIZgIklXf_GJpeMG4wwthBYrf3nPGD4jhAwUZ90EGk9uzvCi9eJWV0qhDT1WfUcNnGfYyJuI8HzuyY8N6yNayhJneObVAprqKWPwS2zr9ljH_CRg8-R4d4hI0PNCJlHUar36WRif8OLBguC6CyIAFpKdZIxqEDPJvG78n_dNI9LQ06fZU18HcObWufsRPBdr3CpWWRUIow75YtVZ2QRBEyut53rA55Zk-50DkOVOmHP7W4DfCoSUowHAPnfg8ZRZVzdCqOjrx19WySMRAoIECI2sETHpUWMacIECKzr1P3CU3GInN85lfModCa7S1ZDPtPbIQMVEkGtS5WVtuHiz-Ebsa9C3Y6sBkzISUjM4a8IfHIzS6zbhqEFlAgjuFjjIfKecJEoaFtIG9oYz8RufvSHVAuLyPUZ0mCGJnCUvNu6cofjnHUXtlWEoaV6ivq_GVA4FUmY_K-ZAD4kneOEemhko4Y9E-IQabwWPAjYZ-S4pkC3If2UxN0zY2x68xEgExkjJU5XlIjrgEKCgr1SxCo7w5XA4OCkATqm9gm_GnZV-vBpZwSeOEwriS11TfH67aVHqjBIHqxsuA3UA)) and non-gravitational acceleration (published [here](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-018-0254-4)), I argued 8 years ago [here](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2110.15213v1) that *1I/Oumuamua* might be pushed by sunlight and is technological in origin. The dark comet categorization of 1I/Oumuamua* and similar solar system objects was the mainstream response to my nontraditional suggestion. The stakes for *1I/Oumuamua being technological in origin are much higher than for 1998 KY26, because its high speed cannot be of human origin. Realizing in July 2031 that 1998 KY26 is technological rather than a dark comet’ would suggest that maybe comet experts should not be trusted and *1I/Oumuamua* is the first encounter of astronomers with alien technology. As I said all along, Elon Musk is probably not the most accomplished space entrepreneur over the past 13.8 billion years. There are billions of homes similar to Earth in our cosmic street of the Milky-Way galaxy and it is unreasonable to suggest that there are no space agencies beyond Earth. ABOUT THE AUTHOR (Image Credit: Lotem Loeb, May 22, 2026) Avi Loeb is chair of the UAP Science Advisory Council to the White House, Pentagon, FBI and intelligence agencies, director of the Galileo Project, founding director of Harvard University’s — Black Hole Initiative (2016–2021), former director of the Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (2005–2026), and the former chair of the astronomy department at Harvard University (2011–2020). He is a former member of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2018–2019) and a former chair of the Board on Physics and Astronomy of the National Academies (2018–2021). He is the bestselling author of “Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth” and a co-author of the textbook “Life in the Cosmos”, both published in 2021. The paperback edition of his new book, titled “Interstellar”, was published in August 2024. Professional website: https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/ Social media: https://avi-loeb.medium.com/ https://www.youtube.com/@ProfessorAviLoeb https://open.spotify.com/show/1zhndXkvSY2b8FdjspFpCd https://x.com/ProfAviLoeb
MIDDLE EASTALASKACARL SAGANADAM CRAWL
Nautilus | Science ConnectedThe New York Times - Breaking News, US News, World News and VideosMeteored US
MediumMedium
EARTH SPACE CLIMATE AND ENVIRONMENT

Q&A About the Observable Universe

(Image Credit: X/UFO Coin) Below is a Q&A exchange that I had with the founder of a Croatian online publication dedicated to science, astronomy, and space exploration. The questions are in boldfaced font. *** With the “fuller” data now available on 3I/ATLAS, what is your assessment of the object? Which features you initially highlighted now have satisfactory explanations, and which, if any, still strike you as unresolved? How likely is it that an object of technological origin has passed through our solar system without us detecting it? 3I/ATLAS displayed the chemical composition and speed of an iceberg which originated from a star that is about twice as old as the Sun. Its main anomalies are that it came within 5 degrees from the orbital plane of the planets around the Sun (corresponding to a random chance of a fraction of a percent); it displayed a major anti-tail jet pointed at the Sun and three mini-jets that are symmetrically organized around its nucleus instead of a standard cometary tail; it released organic molecules, and a deuterium abundance that is a thousand times higher than the cosmic value. It is possible that the organic molecules indicate the potential for microbial life in its deep interior or that its unusual trajectory implies that its cometary appearance represents a Trojan Horse inside of which a technological civilization planted probes inside of it, but we have no direct evidence for any of these possibilities. The Galileo Project has reported triangulation results, and you have announced a new observatory in Ithaca. What has the Project learned so far, and what should the planned combination of radar, high-resolution imaging and spectroscopy make possible that was missing before? Out of all the infrared videos released by the All-Domain Anomaly Resolution Office in the Pentagon over the past five months, the UAP Science Advisory Council in partnership with the Galileo Project (in a paper here led by Jacob Haqq-Misra), found that 8% of the Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) are birds. Triangulation data (as discussed in a Galileo Project paper here) allows us to validate any such inference by measuring the distances of UAP. The bird identification was based on a frame-by-frame analysis which implied that these UAP flicker about 7–8 times per second, similarly to birds in the Galileo Project data. The periodic fluctuations in the amount of heat emitted by these UAP is the result of birds flapping their wings. A couple of months ago, I invented a new observatory concept here which is optimized for high-resolution imaging and spectroscopy of Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP). This idea materialized into a funded construction plan of a new Galileo observatory at the old residence of Carl Sagan in Ithaca (as announced here). A passive radar system will identify UAP in the sky and steer a 0.7-meter sized telescope to obtain a high-resolution image and a spectrum of the UAP. The high-resolution image will allow us to identify fine details in the image (such as see passengers through the windows of a commercial airplane, and the spectrum will allow us to identify the chemical composition of the UAP. Rubin has already announced thousands of new asteroids and a dwarf-planet candidate. What would you most like its future interstellar-object discoveries to reveal, and what discovery rate do you now consider realistic over the coming years? The Rubin Observatory is capable of detecting dozens of new interstellar objects over the coming decade. Right now, its operations are slowed-down by a power outage from severe winter storms in Chile and the Observatory is currently powered by a generator. Your population calculations suggest that vast numbers of interstellar objects could occupy the enormous volume extending out to the Oort Cloud. Which assumption most strongly controls those estimates, and what could a larger observed sample tell us about how planetary systems eject their material? There should be of order a quadrillion (10^{15}) interstellar objects larger than a football field, about 100 meters, out to the edge of the Solar System at a distance of 100,000 times the Earth-Sun separation. This is based on the detection of 1I/Oumuamua, 2I/Borisov and 3I/ATLAS over the past decade, folding in the surveyed volume and detection rate for these objects. The assumption underlying this estimate is that these objects move randomly and are uniformly distributed in the local interstellar space. If any objects are guided by technology, they might target the inner solar system and be more clustered there than on average. This situation is similar to bees which are clustered around flowers. **You helped predict the spectral signatures of the first generation of stars decades ago. With Webb observations now pointing to candidates such as Hebe near GN-z11, what evidence would convince you that we have identified a population of primordial stars, and what would you most want to learn from it?** I would like to know how early the first stars formed. My theoretical prediction from papers published over the past three decades is that the very first stars formed 50 million years after the Big Bang. But if any stars existed when the Universe was 15 million years old, then they would have witnessed what I called in a 2014 paper [here](https://arxiv.org/pdf/1312.0613) “The Habitable Epoch” of the Universe, when the cosmic microwave background was at room temperature. Habitable planets at that time would not need to be in the Goldilocks zone at the right distance from stars in order for the chemistry of life-as-we-know-it to emerge in liquid water on their surface, because the entire volume of the Universe had the right temperature. **Your recent work explores whether material shed by supermassive stars could explain the dense gas surrounding Webb’s “Little Red Dots,” before those stars collapse into massive black-hole seeds. What observation would most clearly distinguish that picture from competing explanations?** My six latest papers on Little Red Dots (listed [here](https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/search/fq=%7B!type%3Daqp%20v%3D%24fq_database%7D&fq_database=database%3A%20astronomy&q=author%3A(%22Loeb%2C%20A.%22)%20abs%3A(Little%20Red%20Dots)&sort=date%20desc%2C%20bibcode%20desc&p_=0)) show how refined spectroscopic data from the Webb Telescope can distinguish between star clusters and supermassive stars as the seeds of supermassive black holes. The origin of supermassive stars as these seeds, dates back to a paper that I published [here](https://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu/pdf/1994ApJ...432...52L) in 1994 with Fred Rasio, followed by a 1995 paper with my first PhD student Daniel Eisenstein [here](https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/search/fq=%7B!type%3Daqp%20v%3D%24fq_database%7D&fq_database=database%3A%20astronomy&q=author%3A(%22Loeb%2C%20A.%22)%20abs%3A(Little%20Red%20Dots)&sort=date%20desc%2C%20bibcode%20desc&p_=0), and a 2003 paper with Volker Bromm [here](https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1086/377529/pdf). **You have described pulsars near Sagittarius A as a natural GPS system for mapping spacetime. What could their precise clocks tell us about gravity that would complement black-hole images and observations of orbiting stars?** These pulsars are clocks which change their ticking rate relative to us as they move along their orbit around Sagittarius A*. Detecting pulsars close to the black hole would allow us to test Einstein’s General Relativity as well as measure the spin of the black hole. **In your new paper with the student Oem Trivedi, you investigate whether dark energy might be distributed unevenly. What observable difference would that make, and how could astronomers distinguish it from an ordinary region containing less matter?** Over the past five years, cosmologists identified a potential discrepancy between the expected and observed Hubble expansion rate in the local Universe. The expected value is based on the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background, a relic from the early Universe. In principle, this so-called Hubble tension’ could be explained by a large void that is deficient of dark energy relative to the cosmos at large. Our paper with Oem shows how this possible explanation can be tested by forthcoming data from galaxy surveys and distance indicators. You have asked why life like ours appeared around a Sun-like star at this particular time in cosmic history. Has your recent work on stellar habitability made those circumstances look more typical or more exceptional to you, and how should that influence where we search for life? The most likely explanation for the fact that the Sun is more massive than most stars is that the habitable zone around fainter dwarf stars is closer in, making rocky planets there vulnerable to sterilization by stellar winds and ultraviolet flares. My recommendation is to focus on the search for life near Sun-like stars even though they are rarer than dwarf stars. The likelihood of finding technological signatures of intelligent civilizations depends sensitively on their lifespan which could be rather short relative to the age of the Universe, unless AI and space exploration extend it. You recently argued for a search focused on extraterrestrial artificial intelligence. If the intelligence we encounter is machine-based rather than biological, what should we search for differently, and how can we avoid projecting today’s ideas about AI onto an unknown civilization? The Search for Extraterrestrial AI (which I termed SETAI here) should take into account that AI data centers are likely to be located closer to the host star than the habitable zone distance, because of the increase in stellar power per unit area. Moreover, AI-assisted robots might appear in the form of self-replicating probes near Earth. Your work with your former postdoc James Guillochon proposes searching for light leaking from beams that could propel hypothetical extraterrestrial light sails. What would such a signal look like in telescope data, and how would researchers separate it from stellar flares or instrumental artifacts? A flare from a beam directed at a light sail would show up in our survey telescopes when our line-of-sight coincides with the beam axis. Our paper calculated the repeating signal that would result from such orientations. This is a new technological signature that was not considered before we studied it in two papers, here and here. You have suggested attaching probes to passing interstellar objects, or eventually using their material to build spacecraft. What would be a credible first experiment toward that idea, and which engineering obstacle would have to be solved first? Our space agencies should consider launching an interceptor that will cross the path of a future interstellar object. As long as we identify the object 6–12 months in advance of its closest distance to Earth, it is feasible to launch an interceptor that will cross its path. One could design a sturdy interceptor payload that would survive the impact with an iceberg and be ultimately carried to interstellar space at a speed that exceeds by a large margin that of the Voyager spacecraft. By hitchhiking a comet with a technological probe or seeding it with life, we can create a Trojan Horse ourselves, as I discussed in a recent paper with my student Shokhruz Kakharov here. The artificial implant may be exposed once the ice around it is vaporized by a close passage to another star. You recently wrote that some public claims misrepresent your views. Has that experience changed how you communicate speculative ideas, especially when the distinction between a possibility and a discovery can disappear in a headline? Most of these misrepresentations resulted from a lack of understanding that progress in science is based on comparing theoretical ideas to experimental data. Without these ideas, we will not be motivated to retrieve new data. This means that we should treat innovative ideas with respect and ultimately accept the ideas that are supported by evidence. But we should not confuse, as done by some science reporters and social media influencers, that a theoretical idea claims a scientific fact. By suggesting the possibility that 1I/`Oumuamua might be technological in origin, I am not claiming that it is. As the fictitious detective Sherlock Holmes noted: “When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.” Many people have a cognitive dissonance when confronted with anomalies. They wish to shove these anomalies under the carpet of traditional thinking and hope that they will disappear, instead of considering non-conventional interpretations for them. The latter is my specialty. For example, see the essay which I wrote this morning here before heading to teach my class. After completing your term as director of Harvard’s Institute for Theory and Computation, what lessons would you pass on about helping young scientists pursue unconventional questions while maintaining strong standards of evidence? My main lesson is that irrespective of leadership titles, all of us should keep wondering about the mysteries of the Universe around us with childlike curiosity. I am much more excited about fostering curiosity in the students and postdocs that I mentor than anything else. The hundreds of young scholars who worked with me share my academic DNA. This morning, I taught a class about gravitational waves. Traditional astronomy was about detecting electromagnetic waves. After reviewing the fundamental theory of gravitational waves, I had mentioned that LIGO (the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory) can detect mirror displacements as small as 10^{-17} centimeters, about 10,000 times smaller than the size of a proton, allowing astronomers to study the spacetime fluctuations generated by a merger of stellar-mass black holes at distances of billions of light years. When the MIT physicist Rai Weiss came up with the initiative to construct LIGO, the scientific community dismissed it as not feasible. Even Rai’s close colleagues at MIT recommended to the local administration that no funding would be allocated to the project. Fortunately, Richard Isaacson, the Program Director for Gravitational Physics at the National Science Foundation (NSF) backed Rai’s early laser interferometer concept in the 1970s despite widespread skepticism in the scientific community. Over several decades, Isaacson steadily directed millions of dollars in NSF research grants toward prototype development and guided LIGO until it became the largest project in the agency’s history. When LIGO transitioned from prototype studies to a massive, expensive construction proposal, Walter Massey, who served as NSF Director between 1991–1993, fought to win over both the National Science Board and a hesitant U.S. Congress. His leadership helped secure the initial major construction appropriations needed to build the twin LIGO observatories in Washington and Louisiana, which were awarded the Physics Nobel Prize in 2017 for their detection of black hole mergers. “The lesson is…”, I told my students, “… not to surrender to naysayers. Successful science leaders are judged by their scientific vision and not by their weekly newsletters.” ABOUT THE AUTHOR (Image Credit: Lotem Loeb, May 22, 2026) Avi Loeb is chair of the UAP Science Advisory Council to the White House, Pentagon, FBI and intelligence agencies, director of the Galileo Project, founding director of Harvard University’s — Black Hole Initiative (2016–2021), former director of the Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (2005–2026), and the former chair of the astronomy department at Harvard University (2011–2020). He is a former member of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2018–2019) and a former chair of the Board on Physics and Astronomy of the National Academies (2018–2021). He is the bestselling author of “Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth” and a co-author of the textbook “Life in the Cosmos”, both published in 2021. The paperback edition of his new book, titled “Interstellar”, was published in August 2024. Professional website: https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/ Social media: https://avi-loeb.medium.com/ https://www.youtube.com/@ProfessorAviLoeb https://open.spotify.com/show/1zhndXkvSY2b8FdjspFpCd https://x.com/ProfAviLoeb
ITHACACHILEGALILEO PROJECTOEM TRIVEDI