Skip to content
LAW CRIME AND PUBLIC SAFETY

'Broadview 6' judge rejects feds' bid for mediator after they accuse her of acting as 'prosecutor'

The federal judge presiding over the wreckage of the “Broadview Six” case on Friday smacked down a request from the Justice Department, hours after it accused her of acting as “investigator and prosecutor” and said a neutral third party should be brought in ahead of a potentially explosive Dec. 2 hearing. U.S. District Judge April Perry rejected the feds’ claim that she is acting as a prosecutor. Rather, she said the U.S. Supreme Court has made clear that judges have “inherent” power to determine if someone has committed a fraud on the court. In other words, she wants to know if federal prosecutors in Chicago lied to her about the case. Related - ‘Broadview 6' judge has to decide whether to hold prosecutors accountable after exposing misconduct Perry on Friday cited case law that said, “no matter who allegedly commits a fraud on the court … the court has the inherent power to conduct proceedings to investigate that allegation and, if it is proven, to punish that conduct.” “That is precisely what the court intends to do here,” Perry added. On top of everything else, she said the feds’ latest request was “untimely.” “The government has known for more than five months that the court planned to hold a hearing regarding the conduct of the federal prosecutors in this matter,” Perry wrote, “and for more than three months that potentially privileged communications would be at issue during that hearing.” Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward made the request late Thursday, in just the latest court filing to land on the eve of a deadline Perry had set. She’s ordered U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and three prosecutors who worked the “Broadview Six” case to testify Dec. 2. But the Justice Department complained that legal privileges should block portions of that testimony. So Perry gave the three prosecutors who worked the case until Friday to submit a written version of any potentially privileged testimony for her review. Woodward argued late Thursday that a “special master” or some other “disinterested judicial officer” should rule on the Justice Department’s privilege claims. “This court, having assumed the roles of investigator and prosecutor in addition to its native function as decisionmaker, cannot be the one to rule on the government’s privilege assertions,” Woodward argued in his four-page filing Thursday. “Because this court is acting as judge and investigator,” he added, “it would be exceedingly difficult, if not impossible, for the court itself to decide questions of privilege while also preserving the perception of fairness.” Related - ‘Broadview 6’ prosecutors say they won’t take the Fifth as potentially explosive hearing looms Woodward is the third-highest ranking official in the Justice Department, and he’s earned a reputation for tangling with federal judges. He made national headlines by facing off with U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes in Washington last month, over a golf course President Donald Trump has sought to renovate in the nation’s capital. Woodward made an uneventful appearance in Perry’s courtroom Monday. But Perry has previously accused Woodward of delay tactics. She’s also denied similar requests in recent weeks as the "Broadview Six" hearing draws nearer. In turn, Woodward has floated the idea of turning to the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which could rule on an initial challenge to Perry. The “Broadview Six” case began as a conspiracy prosecution against six Operation Midway Blitz protesters. It collapsed in spectacular fashion in May amid allegations of prosecutor misconduct. While the controversy initially turned on claims against one rank-and-file prosecutor, Perry recently raised concerns about the veracity of statements Boutros and others made to her while the case played out. Related - Broadview 6 hearing set to rock Chicago federal courthouse, but DOJ official could intervene The day the “Broadview Six” case fell apart, for example, Boutros told Perry he had only learned of certain misconduct by his team in late April. Later, he acknowledged he’d received a transcript by email on Oct. 14, 2025, documenting the misconduct at issue. Boutros said he didn’t remember reading it. Separately, his team told Perry in March there were “no communications of any nature from, to, or with anyone outside [the U.S. attorney’s office] (other than the local FBI investigators assigned to the case) regarding any investigatory or charging decisions. “To be crystal clear, this specifically includes anyone in the White House” or at Justice Department headquarters in Washington, prosecutors wrote. Perry originally took the feds at their word that the communications don’t exist, but Boutros’ team has since suggested otherwise.
CHICAGOWASHINGTONMINNESOTAANA REYESAPRIL PERRYANDREW BOUTROS